Get Weekly Marketing Tips
Join 30,000+ marketers and get the best marketing tips every week in your inbox
The latest data from Ahrefs shows that only 12% of the webpages cited in AI answers actually rank in the top 10 positions on Google for that same phrase.
That single stat changes everything about how you should be thinking about your digital marketing strategy. Ranking at the top of Google is no longer enough. If you want to know how to get cited in AI Search, you need a different playbook, one built specifically for how AI tools choose what to recommend.
Tim Cameron-Kitchen, Founder of Exposure Ninja, breaks down exactly what that playbook looks like, using real examples, real data, and a new agentic AI tool from Ahrefs called Agent A.
Get Your Brand Seen in AI Search
Download the AI Search Strategy Checklist built for marketing leaders and CMOs ready to take control of brand visibility in AI Search.
Why Traditional SEO Isn’t Enough Anymore
Search behaviour has changed. People aren’t just typing keywords into Google anymore. They’re asking full questions to ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini, and even inside Google itself, AI-generated answers now pull from multiple sources rather than sending traffic to a single page.
Tim Cameron-Kitchen explains why this breaks the old rules of SEO: “you can be doing really good SEO, getting ranked at the top of Google. It doesn’t necessarily mean that your content is going to be cited by AI tools.”
This means ranking on page one is still valuable, but it’s no longer a proxy for AI visibility. You need to actively optimise for both.
How To Get Cited in AI Search: Four Pillars
Getting cited by AI tools comes down to four pillars: the right topics, the right structure, the right authority signals and the right freshness. Here’s what each one actually involves.
AI likes to see four things: the right topics, the right content structure, the right authority signals, and the right freshness.
Founder
Pillar One: Publish The Right Topics
The problem most businesses run into is that people don’t search AI tools the same way they search Google. A Google search might be a short keyword. A ChatGPT prompt is a full, conversational question.
Tim Cameron-Kitchen uses the example of a lease extension company to show the gap: “People probably aren’t going, ‘lease extension company.’ That might be how they typed in Google, but that’s not the sort of conversation they’re having inside ChatGPT.”
As Tim Cameron-Kitchen puts it, someone is more likely asking “how does a commercial lease extension work and what does it cost”, which is a completely different format, length and intent.
If you’re only optimising content around your existing Google keywords, you’re likely missing the conversational, question-based queries that actually drive AI citations.
This is where Ahrefs’ Agent A comes in. Its SEO to AI query converter skill pulls your existing ranking keywords and matches them against real AI Search queries, surfacing the plain language questions your audience is actually asking these tools.
Pillar Two: Structure Content For Extraction
Once you know what to write about, how you structure it matters just as much. AI tools extract passages from content, so content built for skimming and scanning gets picked up more often.
“If you want to write for extraction, you need clear heading hierarchy, direct answers near the top of the page, short, clear paragraphs, AI really likes lists and tables, and ideally some FAQs,” explains Tim Cameron-Kitchen. “Doing anything that you can to help machines read your content in a more structured way is not going to hurt.”
This shows that the basics of good content structure (clear headings, short paragraphs, tables, FAQs) aren’t just good for readers. They’re good for AI extraction too.
The proof is in the results. Pyramid Eco, one of Exposure Ninja’s own businesses, restructured its site and content around this approach and saw a 10X increase in search visibility, picked up more than 150 backlinks from top-tier publications, and grew conversion rate by 129%.
“The website is now outranking major competitors that have been spending a lot more on marketing over the years and even outranking some of the government’s own pages targeting these topics,” adds Tim Cameron-Kitchen.
Pillar Three: Build Real Authority
AI tools don’t just read what your content says. They weigh up whether you’re credible enough to be worth citing in the first place.
That credibility comes from two places:
- Your own first-party data and experience.
- How much other credible sites talk about you.
This means that publishing generic content isn’t enough. You need original data, E-E-A-T content, and genuine digital PR coverage to prove you’re a trustworthy source.
Elite Renewables is a good example. Its detailed content includes first-party customer service data, which is exactly the kind of unique perspective that makes AI tools and Google more willing to cite it.
Agent A’s brand authority and E-E-A-T audit skill can benchmark this for you automatically, scoring your site against Google’s expertise, experience, authoritativeness and trust criteria.
Pillar Four: Keep Your Content Fresh
The final pillar is freshness. AI tools consistently favour more recent content over older pages, even when the older content still ranks well organically.
“The average age of URLs cited by AI assistants is 1,064 days… regular organic search results, the average age is 1,432 days. So AI tools on average prefer content that is 25.7% fresher,” says Tim Cameron-Kitchen.
This doesn’t mean everything needs republishing constantly, but “generally speaking, the fresher your content is, the more likely it is to be picked up in AI results.”
Agent A’s AI citation freshness audit flags exactly which cited pages have gone stale, so you’re not manually auditing content page by page.
“This basically gives you your to-do list for your content refresh. You just go and pull all of the pieces that are outdated. We know that they’re being cited, so it’s worth doing,” says Tim Cameron-Kitchen.
Getting Cited in AI Search
The four pillars work together. Right topics, right structure, real authority, and consistent freshness. Miss one and you’ll struggle to show up in AI answers, no matter how strong your traditional SEO looks.
If AI Search visibility is becoming a bigger part of how your customers find you, an AI Search Audit can show you exactly where you stand today, how your brand is currently described across AI platforms, and what to prioritise.
Want a strategic partner to help you turn AI Search visibility into real leads and revenue? Book a consultation call with the team at Exposure Ninja and we’ll show you exactly where the opportunities are.
